← writing
5 December 2020

Two ways to open a nut

The chisel or patience: Grothendieck describes two ways of approaching a problem, with different costs. The choice depends on the situation more than on temperament.

Alexandre Grothendieck compares proving a theorem to opening a nut. You can set a chisel against the shell and strike, moving around until it gives way. Or you can leave it to soak until the shell opens under light pressure from the hand. Grothendieck states a clear preference for the second. In engineering, both situations come up every week, and the method is rarely chosen deliberately.

01The chisel

Striking means trying the possibilities until one works. This method has one advantage: it gives an answer within a predictable time. During a production outage that advantage is decisive, because the service has to be restored before the cause is understood. On the other hand it teaches nothing, and a problem solved that way comes back unchanged.

02The soaking

Narrowing means reducing the area where the problem can lie, before trying to solve it. It is slower at first and much faster at the end, and the result can be passed on: what has been bounded remains true after the person who did it has left. However, the method gives no delivery date, which makes it almost impossible to defend in front of a steering committee.

03Diffuse and focused

Barbara Oakley grounds this opposition in concrete observations. Oakley distinguishes two modes of attention, one focused and one diffuse, and shows that the second also contributes to the work. That explains why walking, sleep or a shower help: the phase when you are not thinking about the problem is part of the work. The corollary is awkward, since that phase cannot be scheduled.

“A mathematician is a device for turning coffee into theorems.”
Alfréd Rényi
04Regularity

Both methods depend on regularity. The notebooks of writers, painters and researchers confirm this, often with the same unusual hours and the same chosen isolation. Stephen Wolfram has published a detailed account of a personal working setup, and its stability is more striking than the tooling. When the environment does not change, all the variation is in the problem.

05When to choose which

Neither method is right in every case. The chisel applied to a problem that needed time produces a temporary fix; soaking applied to an incident is expensive for the client. The skill is recognising which situation you are in, and it comes from the number of cases met more than from reading.