← writing
19 November 2020

Negotiating scope, not price

Four traditions say the same thing about cooperation: the room to negotiate lies in what gets done, seldom in the amount. The position I took from them, and what it costs.

The price of an engagement is discussed once and settled in ten minutes. Scope is discussed for the whole engagement. It took me a while to see that this second discussion determines the outcome of the first. A fair rate on a vague scope ends up as a bad rate, whereas with a precise scope the rate becomes almost secondary.

01The abundance mindset, and its condition

Stephen Covey places cooperation under what Covey calls public victory, and bases it on a simple idea: there will be enough for everyone. The idea holds in a lasting relationship, which produces more than it divides. It fails in a one-off negotiation whose budget is fixed before the first meeting, which happens more often than people admit. What I mainly keep is the condition: abundance has to be checked, not assumed.

02Naming expectations before dividing

Barry Nalebuff suggests first naming what each side wants, and only then dividing. The rule sounds obvious. It is hard to apply because the first step is nearly always skipped. When two sides argue over a figure without saying what they would do with it, each holds its position. Game theory describes that deadlock as the prisoner’s dilemma: two decisions that are rational separately and costly for both together.

03Offering to cut, to find out

In the judgement of Solomon, the king offers to divide the child, and it is one woman’s refusal that shows which of the two has more to lose. On an engagement, offering to reduce the scope has the same effect. When I say I can deliver half the scope within the agreed time, the answer tells me more about the project than three scoping workshops, because it shows which parts of the request matter to the client.

04行: not humiliating the other side

The character 行 reads as to walk or to act, and also refers to the way a thing is done. A martial arts maxim adds to it: too clear a victory wounds the opponent’s pride. It is the only one of the four sources concerned with what comes after. Winning a negotiation to the point of humiliating the other side makes delivery harder, and in a trade where the next client often comes from the previous one, that cost is high.

05The price itself

None of this says how to set a price, and I have no method to offer on that point. These four sources deal with the frame of the discussion, not the figure. They apply only to a relationship you want to continue. With a buyer you will not see again they are a disadvantage, and it is better to know that before relying on them.