← writing
20 November 2020

What tidying does not settle

Three method books read in the same year, and their shared limit: they organise a stock, while the scarce resource is attention. What remains of them once that promise is set aside.

Marie Kondo, Tim Ferriss and David Allen do not write about the same subject, but their methods share a structure: an inventory, a sorting rule, a place to put things. For objects it works, because a stored object no longer demands attention. For keeping up with a technical field it fails: a filed article still has to be read, and a well-kept filing system mainly produces the satisfaction of having kept it.

01The archives nobody reopens

Archiving an email instead of deleting it seems prudent but is not. Nobody reopens a three-year-old email. A mailbox that keeps everything accumulates, besides the useless, invoices and confirmations that become a risk the day the account is compromised. Deleting should be the default, and keeping a justified exception.

02The tab count

Three tabs, ten bookmarks. The numbers are arbitrary, and that is intended: the decision is made once instead of being reopened with every new tab. Whatever exceeds the limit is closed or added to a reading list. Clearing the browser regularly shows afterwards what was needed, which is almost nothing.

03Delegating the sorting, warily

A newsletter is sorting done by someone else; a syndication feed lets you read a blog without its layout. Both work better than searching as you go. Automatic recommendations also sort, but towards a goal that is not mine, and that needs remembering every time they are used.

04Long reading

That leaves long reading, the slowest form of sorting and the most useful. An idea that looks new almost always belongs to a history, and knowing it avoids redoing work already done. These three books are still useful for that: they encourage you not to rely only on what has just come out, even if their method does not hold up.

05The promised time saving

None of these habits saves time. They reduce the number of decisions, and the tiredness of a working day comes more often from decisions than from hours. As for the four-hour week, I have never seen anyone achieve it among those whose job is to answer for systems in production.